Showing posts with label plagiarism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plagiarism. Show all posts

Monday, 28 June 2010

Tin eye

Just been told about this new "image plagiarism" tool : http://www.tineye.com/.  It helps you reverse search for an image. Useful also for catching up on the results of those Friday afternoon Photoshop tennis sessions (b3ta.com)

Thursday, 13 August 2009

concerns for HE(A)

Quango man has your cash!


In a recent House of Commons report entitled Students and Universities the Higher Education Academy effectivley receive a vote of no confidence, as do the QAA!! Testing times ahead for both Quangos me thinks?

"We remain concerned that the Academy could not demonstrate what value it added for the
money supplied by the taxpayer or show that it was providing good value for money."

The Times Higher has summarised the report here. And also pulls out some very interesting bullet points, among them is this old chestnut:

Plagiarism by students is a “serious problem”, and there needs to be further investigation into why UK students appear to spend less time studying than their peers elsewhere in Europe.

So it looks like the QAA need to improve/regroup/disappear, etc, and try and reduce the fraudulent claims by some top Universities claiming for students who had left courses early. The Guardian also report on how they intend to keep closer tabs on the QAA to try and abate these poor management practices by public funded Universities.

And while were at revamping the entire education sector, 800 Quangos (like the Academy, JISC, Becta, fDf, LSC, etc, etc) are all in for severe pruning if the Tories get in next, or indeed when the recession bites harder after the next election.

I'll get me coat :O/ ....... Time for a holiday :oD

Friday, 31 October 2008

Catch-copy-catch


I'm due to give a few presentations this month to academics on the current state of play regarding the technology to used in the continuing battle against bad scholarly practice. Yes I mean coping with plagiarism and collusion in assessments. You may remember in the summer I reported on the results of the three year survey on the (approx 50%) accuracy of Turnipin the popular text matching software. Well I've been trawling some JISCmail plagiarism posts to bring you some nuggets of effective practice and recent innovations in this area.

  • The second blog post discussed a new pebblepad plug-in and a comparison of text matching tools.

  • Please access the wealth of papers and presentations from June's 3rd International Plagiarism Conference are now available at www.plagiarismconference.co.uk .

  • I learned this summer that two academic experts based at the University of Birmingham and Aston University are collaborating to create their own text matching tool. Someone please tell me more about this and how it's progressing.

  • At the ALT-C conference in Sept 08 I was given some excellent student Turnitin crib sheets from the Elearning department @ Teesside Uni. I did try to find a link to electronic copies, but to no avail. If they were made public, they would make a good tool for all UK HE staff. Let us know if you've developed you own resources you would like to share.

  • There is a new Electronic Theses Online Service (EThOSnet) project web site. : http://www.ethos.ac.uk/ . EThOS is: Improving research theses access to those who need it . Improving post graduate research knowledge transfer to students Creating a one stop electronic shop for all UK Theses. Promoting UK Higher Education post graduate research to the world .Contributing to the global knowledge pool.

  • An effective and tested approach that one University uses to improve scholarly practice/referencing skills:

1. find a willing volunteer who has handed some draft work in and use the work as an example with the rest of the class highlighting good and bad practice


2. showing students suitable (nameless) examples from the previous year's cohort


  • Toby Grainger at The University of East London
    has developed a very short and simple policy for academic misconduct and the use of text matching software. He gave it out to JISCmail subscribers, so I'm sure he'd be happy to let others use it as a basis for customisation.


  • For the BB users out there, a new (July 08) tool called Safe-assign that plugs into the VLE. Use instead of or as well as Turnitin?

  • "Smart students" check their drafts for plagiarism even before going to tutors, which is not a bad thing given some of the conversations I've just read. Be a smarter student using this free service, I just stumbled across : http://www.plagiarismdetect.com/

    Free plagiarism detection
UPDATE!!! A number of experts have checked this site , since the post and all pulled it to pieces regarding it's usefulness. One academic categorises it as a cheat site. Be warned, treat this "site" with skepticism
  • I just discovered the UK Research Integrity Office (UKRIO), which is an independent body which offers advice and guidance to universities and other research organisations, and also to individual researchers, about the conduct of research. Hosted by Universities UK, our aims are to: Promote the good governance, management and conduct of research; Share good practice on how to address misconduct in research; and Give advice and guidance on specific cases. They have developed a Procedure for the Investigation of Misconduct in Research



Friday, 18 July 2008

Turnitin plugin for pebblepad



Rumour has it that PebblePad (the eportfolio tool) has developed a new beta version that incorporates the Turnitin - text matching tool. which is nice :o).

I just stumbled across this old posting about grading TII with other "text - matching" systems. IT was done in 2007, but still fairly relevant?
http://copy-shake-paste.blogspot.com/2007/09/test-of-plagiarism-detection-software.html

Wednesday, 18 June 2008

Turnitin and text matching




  • Dr Niaill Hayes described (at the ASKe CETL one-day conference on institutional management of plagiarism) a three year study, just finished in May 2008, funded by FDTL5 and based at the University of Lancaster and the LSE. The study attempted to 'get inside' plagiarism detection software systems to try and understand the underpinning assumptions and procedures that the system creators were using. They tested 15,000 fragments of text to try and gauge the likelihood that any student's copied text would be identified by Turnitin. They found the likelihood to be about 50% - that is, students who copied had about a 50/50 chance of being identified though of course, this is a crude number and would be impacted by other factors such as where the student copied from etc.

    It certainly confirms the widely held view that the software NOT finding a match does not mean the text is not copied. [apologies for all those negatives]


    The above statement was a precis provided by Jude Carroll to me, three weeks ago. Her 10 minute plagiarism video housed at the Nottingham Uni best practice web portal is well worth a look.

    The research also looked into the use of illegal characters (see Guardian link below) used by some to dupe the system, and also the interpretation of the originality report. Full report is out soon. We are waiting from an official reply from JISCiPAS the JISC plagiarism advisory service that supports manages the TII database UK franchise.


    To conclude

    Don’t over hype the capabilities of TII – as has patently already occurred across academia. The implementation and subsequent use of this type of software MUST be part of a holistic range of measures that educates both staff and students to the requirement for scholarly practice at higher levels. JISCiPAS as an organisation do this extremely well. Please take time to visit the excellent resources on their website. http://www.jiscpas.ac.uk/ . The move towards more creative ways of assessing student capabilities is beginning to gather momentum. The use of group work, vivas, computer aided assessments, and more personal reflections are all being promoted as alternatives to the traditional essay, which, coupled with the (misuse of) internet are blamed for the ease/rise of plagiarism.

    Further reading:

    Other relevant Plagiarism news is rife at present and reinforces beliefs on students “buying” more ready-made essays and the shortfalls of TII’s algorithms.

  • Essay auctions 'harder to catch':
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/education/7302641.stm
  • A new AMBeR report just published by the Academy
http://www.heacademy.ac.uk/news/detail/uk_report_student_plagiarism

http://www.ics.heacademy.ac.uk/resources/assessment/plagiarism/